Skip to main content

Sixth Circuit Reverse Conviction Based on Bad Traffic Stop

Published on:  

What do you get when you combine a routine traffic stop with the driver's criminal history, several air fresheners in the car, driving from a job interview, and the driver's movements while looking for proof of insurance? Knoxville, Tenn. drug interdiction officer: Reasonable suspicion of drugs that justifies prolonging the stop to request a drug dog? (Which reveals an illegal gun but no drugs.) Sixth Circuit: No! And no good-faith exception. Evidence of the illegal gun should have been suppressed. Reversed and remanded.

The case is United States v. Nathaniel Taylor, No. 23-5344 (6th Cir. 2024).