Skip to main content

Motions

Fourth Circuit Finds Fourth Amendment Violation For Phone Search, Rejects 'Good Faith'

Navy investigators get a warrant to seize—and only seize—a sailor's phone. They search it anyway and find the bad things, but the district court suppresses the evidence. On appeal, the prosecution pleads "good faith" reliance on a defective warrant. Fourth Circuit: The warrant wasn't defective. You just didn't follow it. The good faith exception "is not a panacea that can save the Government when all remaining facts and law fail." Bugger off. Dismissal affirmed.

Sixth Circuit Dismisses Innocent Man's Malicious Prosecution Suit

Over the course of 10 years, Louisville, Ky. man is indicted and re-indicted six times on 34 charges including murder, rape, kidnapping—all over the same nexus of events that took place in 2004. He spends over seven years in prison. But wait! The state drops the murder charge in 2015 and then all the rest of the charges in 2016. He missed out on the chance to share births, funerals, and time with his five children, along with the opportunity to “fall in love, to marry and enjoy the fundamental freedom … of a human being.” Malicious prosecution?

Fourth Circuit Upholds Geofence Warrant, But Can’t Agree On Reason (2025)

One of the most-read novellas of all time, Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness, clocks in at, depending on what edition you pick up, around 120 pages. Not to be outdone, the 15-judge en banc Fourth Circuit provides 126 pages of eight non-precedential concurrences, plus one dissent, in addressing whether geofence warrants are unconstitutional.

Seventh Circuit: 'Even One Second of Continued Detention After An Unlawful Stop Is Too Long'

Black teen, turkey in hand four days before Christmas, gets stopped and frisked by Milwaukee cops Justin Schwarzhuber and Jasen Rydzewski—waiting to see if any “new fresh robberies [had] come over” the radio. Teen is unarmed, cooperative, and still held for 20 minutes with no charges, no paperwork, and zero explanation. Teen: Fourth Amendment violation! District court: qualified immunity, case dismissed. 7th Circuit: Totally uncool.

Sixth Circuit Reject Immunity From Exonoree's Suit

Detroit man spends more than 20 years in prison for a 12-year-old girl's murder—a crime he did not commit. Indeed, another man's fingerprints are on the murder weapon, and the defendant's confession (which got the cause of death wrong) followed a detective's telling him he could go home after signing it. Once he's released, he sues the city and involved officials who, as you might expect, assert qualified immunity.

Tenth Circuit Vacates Convictions In Indian Country Sex Cases For Burden Shifting

Man is convicted of sex crimes in Indian country against an Indian victim under statute that applies if either the perpetrator or victim is an Indian—but does not apply if both are. Man: The feds didn't show I am not an Indian. Feds: That's your fault for not objecting to the jury instructions. Tenth Circuit: That's your fault for not proving an essential element of the crime. Convictions reversed.

The case is United States v. Simpkins, No. 22-7048 (10th Cir. Jan. 24, 2024).